[KIDS] QC coadds for KiDS-INT-DR2

[Gijs Verdoes Kleijn]

Thanks for input Lino,

That comparison is in the realm of QC catalogs with Mario, using his 
software.
If I'm correct using DR8 and aperture corrections.

Jeffrey, you have KiDS-SDSS comparison working within Astro-WISE, right?
If I'm correct using DR7 and no aperture corrections.
If above is correct: would be good to know if we can update the 
Astro-WISE version to DR8+aperture corrections.

Best wishes, Gijs

Op 20-11-2012 15:47, aniello grado schreef:
> Dear Gijs and Ewout,
>
> in my opinion we should definitely add the photometric comparison with
> SLOAN, i.e. plots with residuals vs RA and DEC.
>
> Lino
>
> On Tue, Nov 20, 2012 at 1:59 PM, Gijs Verdoes Kleijn
> <verdoes at astro.rug.nl> wrote:
>> Dear COADD-QC-TEAM,
>>
>> A first prototype of our quality-assessment table for coadds is available.
>> Please find it :
>> http://wiki.astro-wise.org/projects:kids:data_deliveries:internaldelivery2.0_scratch#data
>> It contains links per coadd to its quality-wise page plus its PSF end-to-end
>> figure.
>>
>> The final quality-assessment table shall be delivered next week.
>> I propose to finalize the content and lay-out of the full quality-assessment
>> table by Friday this week.
>> So first question is: which additional quality assessment results should we
>> add?
>>
>> Best wishes, Gijs and Ewout
>>
>>
>> On 11/15/2012 12:13 PM, Gijs Verdoes Kleijn wrote:
>>
>> Dear COADD-QC-TEAM, dear Nicola as lead of QC catalog team.
>>
>> We have the following QC checks in place:
>>
>> DONE: visual inspection (using QualityWISE), to identify processing issues
>> DONE?/EMH: PSF difference between CoaddedRegriddedFrame and input
>> ReducedScienceFrames: see verify method in RegriddedFrame.py
>> DONE: consistency check on input RegriddedFrames
>>
>> These are either in the general verify method for CoaddedRegriddedFrames in
>> RegriddedFrame.py or the KiDS-INT-DR2 specific code: qcCoadd_INTDR2.py
>>
>> I propose as next step deciding which additional checks are needed for
>> KiDS-INT-DR2 at coadd level:
>>   * AG+GVK+team: completion of QC coadd checks, using QC criteria coadd as
>> starting point.
>>
>> For this we need to define the scope of QC coadd: where does QC coadd end
>> and QC catalog begin. I think a clear division is to leave to QC catalog
>> team als those QC checks that can only be done well with good catalogs. So
>> also those that check rather the coadd quality then catalog quality. QC
>> coadd lead Lino + Gijs can be liaison to QC catalog team to help the QC
>> catalog team in those cases.
>>
>> What does QC coadd team deliver for KiDS-INT-DR2?:
>> My proposal:
>> 1.the QualityWISE page: those we have in hand, they come for free with
>> Astro-WISE coadd production. Input on improving the plots presented there is
>> welcome.
>> 2. A set of additional plots and/or numbers per coadd that complements the
>> QualityWISE page with KiDS-INT-DR2 specific stuff. This can be either
>> presented as one page per coadd or gallery of a certain plot for the 52
>> coadds. Danny is looking into this. I see this set as an experiment from
>> which we can choose how to develop QualityWISE further after KiDS team
>> meeting in December.
>>
>> Discussion has opened: all input welcomed (keep emailing
>> kids at astro-wise.org!)
>>
>> Above information and more is contained at our wiki spot for
>> COADD-QC-KIDS-INT-DR2:
>> http://wiki.astro-wise.org/projects:kids:data_deliveries:internaldelivery2.0_scratch#qc_based_on_coaddedregriddedframes
>>
>> Best wishes, Gijs
>>
>> --
>> --------------------------------------------------------------------
>> |dr Gijs Verdoes Kleijn         |   astronomer                     |
>> |e-mail: verdoes at astro.rug.nl   |   OmegaCEN / Kapteyn Institute / |
>> |www: www.astro.rug.nl/~verdoes |   Target                         |
>> |tel: +31-50-3638326            |   University of Groningen        |
>> |mobile: +31-654658050          |   postal address:                |
>> |                               |   Kapteyn Astronomical Institute |
>> |                               |   Postbus 800, 9700 AV, Groningen|
>> |                               |   The Netherlands                |
>> --------------------------------------------------------------------
>>
>>
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> KiDS mailing list
>> KiDS at astro-wise.org
>> http://listman.astro-wise.org/mailman/listinfo/kids
>>
>>
>> --
>> --------------------------------------------------------------------
>> |dr Gijs Verdoes Kleijn         |   astronomer                     |
>> |e-mail: verdoes at astro.rug.nl   |   OmegaCEN / Kapteyn Institute / |
>> |www: www.astro.rug.nl/~verdoes |   Target                         |
>> |tel: +31-50-3638326            |   University of Groningen        |
>> |mobile: +31-654658050          |   postal address:                |
>> |                               |   Kapteyn Astronomical Institute |
>> |                               |   Postbus 800, 9700 AV, Groningen|
>> |                               |   The Netherlands                |
>> --------------------------------------------------------------------
>>
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> KiDS mailing list
>> KiDS at astro-wise.org
>> http://listman.astro-wise.org/mailman/listinfo/kids
>>
>
>

-- 
--------------------------------------------------------------------
|dr Gijs Verdoes Kleijn         |   astronomer                     |
|e-mail: verdoes at astro.rug.nl   |   OmegaCEN / Kapteyn Institute / |
|www: www.astro.rug.nl/~verdoes |   Target                         |
|tel: +31-50-3638326            |   University of Groningen        |
|mobile: +31-654658050          |   postal address:                |
|                               |   Kapteyn Astronomical Institute |
|                               |   Postbus 800, 9700 AV, Groningen|
|                               |   The Netherlands                |
--------------------------------------------------------------------